LinuxQuestions.org

LinuxQuestions.org (/questions/)
-   Debian (https://www.linuxquestions.org/questions/debian-26/)
-   -   Locking up on Reboot (https://www.linuxquestions.org/questions/debian-26/locking-up-on-reboot-4175733782/)

poncedeleon 02-12-2024 08:43 AM

Locking up on Reboot
 
Running LMDE Elisa. When rebooting or installing new updates and reboot, 60% of the time when the LM icon comes up the system locks requiring to reboot. This has been going on for a year and with the latest update last evening after three reboots before I had access to my system I wanted to pose this question to the community for help.

Has anyone else had this issue? How do I go about solving this persistent issue?

Thanks

rclark 02-13-2024 04:56 PM

So hitting 'esc' key while locked up doesn't show you anything? One of my machines stalls once in awhile when unmounting a nfs mount point on exit (hitting esc shows you the exit messages instead of splash screen), but it eventually times out and reboots... unless I get impatient and hit the reset button.

jefro 02-13-2024 05:51 PM

Unfortunatly reboot on many computers doesn't fully act like a full power down. Some circuits may still have gates set or power applied.

Test maybe. Full power down. Remove ac. Press power button a few times then test if powers up.

poncedeleon 02-14-2024 07:02 AM

When there is another lockup I will try the two suggestions offered by jefro and rclark.

hazel 02-14-2024 08:27 AM

Could be the drive. My computer stopped rebooting months ago. Cold start, no problem, but a reboot always got stuck, either while loading elilo or loading the kernel. Then I discovered, quite by accident, that the drive was about to fail.

With the help of the community, I installed a new SSD and now the machine reboots without problems.

TB0ne 02-14-2024 09:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by poncedeleon (Post 6483037)
Running LMDE Elisa. When rebooting or installing new updates and reboot, 60% of the time when the LM icon comes up the system locks requiring to reboot. This has been going on for a year and with the latest update last evening after three reboots before I had access to my system I wanted to pose this question to the community for help.

Has anyone else had this issue? How do I go about solving this persistent issue?

Have you actually done ANY troubleshooting??? Looked at any of the log files on the system?? Could be one of a thousand things, but you've (again) provided no details. Hard to imagine that you've been dealing with this for a YEAR and not done anything to look deeper into it. Done anything on a basic level, like perhaps booting from USB and running an fsck on your drives?? Looking at smartctl to see if you're having drive issues??? Checked the memory??? ANYTHING???

hazel 02-14-2024 10:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TB0ne (Post 6483550)
Hard to imagine that you've been dealing with this for a YEAR and not done anything to look deeper into it. Done anything on a basic level, like perhaps booting from USB and running an fsck on your drives?? Looking at smartctl to see if you're having drive issues??? Checked the memory??? ANYTHING???

I didn't either, to be honest, when the same thing happened to me. I just thought, "Oh well, it's an old computer, perhaps it just can't reboot any more". Admittedly I wasn't running a distro that required a reboot after updating (actually I thought only Windows did that).

The way I found out that my drive was on the verge of failing was a complete accident. I was trying to install AntiX-23 and it ran smartctl as part of the installation procedure and gave me a dire warning. I screamed for help and the LQ community took over, told me what further tests to run to be sure of the matter, and guided me in buying and installing a new drive. And no one bit my head off!!

TB0ne 02-14-2024 10:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hazel (Post 6483559)
I didn't either, to be honest, when the same thing happened to me. I just thought, "Oh well, it's an old computer, perhaps it just can't reboot any more". Admittedly I wasn't running a distro that required a reboot after updating (actually I thought only Windows did that).

The way I found out that my drive was on the verge of failing was a complete accident. I was trying to install AntiX-23 and it ran smartctl as part of the installation procedure and gave me a dire warning. I screamed for help and the LQ community took over, told me what further tests to run to be sure of the matter, and guided me in buying and installing a new drive. And no one bit my head off!!

There is a difference between someone who is new, and someone with years of experience. The OP has experience, and has been asked NUMEROUS times to actually provide details and do at least some troubleshooting, but they don't. Feel free to check the OP's posting history.

Saying something like, "I've tried to check the logs, but don't see anything", or at the very least what hardware they're running. But we get nothing past their desktop environment an version of Debian, and are somehow supposed to guess??? What did you post when you had a problem; actual details, or just something vague??

No, thanks..at some point, posters have to provide details and information without folks having to repeatedly ask.

hazel 02-14-2024 11:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TB0ne (Post 6483571)
What did you post when you had a problem; actual details, or just something vague??

https://www.linuxquestions.org/quest...ve-4175730018/

That thread contains nothing about the earlier reboot failures because I had no idea before reading this thread that the two things could be connected. Now I think they probably were. Maybe the OP should run the specific smartmon tests that I was told to run and post the results.

TB0ne 02-14-2024 11:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hazel (Post 6483575)
https://www.linuxquestions.org/quest...ve-4175730018/

That thread contains nothing about the earlier reboot failures because I had no idea before reading this thread that the two things could be connected. Now I think they probably were. Maybe the OP should run the specific smartmon tests that I was told to run and post the results.

And that thread contains at least some details about your system, the fact you noticed disk diagnostics (smartctl), that you have backups, haven't seen any boot-up errors/problems, and at least have SOMETHING to work with. Far different than, "It's been acting flaky for a year, and I just keep rebooting until it works".

_blackhole_ 02-15-2024 07:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by poncedeleon (Post 6483037)
Running LMDE Elisa. When rebooting or installing new updates and reboot, 60% of the time when the LM icon comes up the system locks requiring to reboot.

If there is no response from ESC during the lock up, then try magic sys rq key combinations:

https://www.kernel.org/doc/html/late...agic-sysrq-key

If there's no response even from those, you most likely have a hardware issue.

mrapathy 02-16-2024 12:00 AM

boot to command line and maybe see if X or something more to go on problem wise.

poncedeleon 02-18-2024 08:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TB0ne (Post 6483571)
There is a difference between someone who is new, and someone with years of experience. The OP has experience, and has been asked NUMEROUS times to actually provide details and do at least some troubleshooting, but they don't. Feel free to check the OP's posting history.

Saying something like, "I've tried to check the logs, but don't see anything", or at the very least what hardware they're running. But we get nothing past their desktop environment an version of Debian, and are somehow supposed to guess??? What did you post when you had a problem; actual details, or just something vague??

No, thanks..at some point, posters have to provide details and information without folks having to repeatedly ask.

TBOne I have had you on the ignore list but this time I must tell you how arrogant, judgmental, and an irritation you inflict upon the Linux community. You criticize EVERYONE and assume someone is knowledgeable based on their posts. You offer NO kind support and frankly are hateful. Maybe in your mind you feel you are being helpful ,,,,well maybe its your narcissistic tendencies.

I have no education with computers and the science. Linux I love but do not have the knowledge you presume I have. But to see you come back at a "little old lady" who does her best to provide support with kindness is very repulsive. You are an old fart as the saying goes.

Myself I have decided to go back to Windows to escape the criticism of persons like yourself TBOne. It is insulting and an irritation to this fine Linux Community. Who put YOU in charge????

Hazel, thanks so much for your help in the past and I do wish there were more persons like you. Bless you Hazel.

TB0ne 02-18-2024 08:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by poncedeleon (Post 6484413)
TBOne I have had you on the ignore list but this time I must tell you how arrogant, judgmental, and an irritation you inflict upon the Linux community. You criticize EVERYONE and assume someone is knowledgeable based on their posts. You offer NO kind support and frankly are hateful. Maybe in your mind you feel you are being helpful ,,,,well maybe its your narcissistic tendencies.

I have no education with computers and the science. Linux I love but do not have the knowledge you presume I have. But to see you come back at a "little old lady" who does her best to provide support with kindness is very repulsive. You are an old fart as the saying goes.

Myself I have decided to go back to Windows to escape the criticism of persons like yourself TBOne. It is insulting and an irritation to this fine Linux Community. Who put YOU in charge????

Excellent, glad you're going to use something else if providing basic details is too much for you to do, to try to get help from a group of volunteers. "Kind support" is offered (and was), but that fell off after having repeatedly had to try to pry information out of you. No one was asking you to be a programmer, have 'education with computers and science', etc., but just something BASIC. Yet you don't and haven't...maybe you think you are, but if you want to criticize someone for getting fed up with behavior like yours, then you just aren't paying attention.

If you think that using Windows is going to magically make people on Microsoft forums mind-readers (as you seemingly expect US to be), it won't. They, too, are going to ask you questions and will also get fed up after years of having to ask over and over. This thread is an excellent example...myself and several others asked things, and you don't bother answering, but seem to have time to post an insulting rant.

And hazel needs help from NO ONE, and I certainly didn't insult or criticize her or "come back at" anyone, but pointed out your seeming unwillingness to ever provide any sort of details when having your hand out for help.

hazel 02-18-2024 10:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TB0ne (Post 6484419)
And hazel needs help from NO ONE, and I certainly didn't insult or criticize her or "come back at" anyone, but pointed out your seeming unwillingness to ever provide any sort of details when having your hand out for help.

In fact I very often need help and I have had some from you in the past, as well as from many others here. And I certainly didn't read your comments in #10 as in any way derogatory. But I do think that you are often too harsh in your judgements on certain other people.

@poncedeleon: please read the earlier thread which I referenced in #9 and carry out the smartmonctl commands that I was told to run. Compare the results with those that I posted. If they are at all similar, especially in the two variables that other posters draw attention to, then do as I did and get a new drive. And don't go back to Windows!!! Do you really want a system that locks up for a half-hour compulsory update every other time you boot it?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:51 PM.