Switching to Gentoo
Hi im planning on using Gentoo is this a good distro?
|
Yes Gentoo is a good distribution.
|
Quote:
For me, Gentoo gives me the flexibility to install only what I want/need (USE flags) and everything is installed optimized for my PC. Which means no system bloating with unused libraries and possibly some performance gain; this is what I expect from a good distro. Serafean |
@SBN, what kind of box do you have, because with Gentoo, you need to compile your programs.
|
Quote:
My 1.2 GHz AMD Athlon machine is very responsive these days. I run XFCE4 window manager and use e.g. Abiword instead of openoffice. It is of course an advantage to have a machine you can leave on overnight for the compiles. With older hardware it takes time to compile it all, but when its done its very fast. Mons |
To the original poster: you will need to supply more information if you truly want an useful response from us. "Good" can be lots of things.
Quote:
The true power of Gentoo is in customization, being USE flags one of the main strengths for me. With a simple combination of use flags you can make mplayer to have 100 or 2 dependencies. That's true power. All of that with proper dependency resolution and without having to deal with configure scripts. Quote:
|
Its definately true that we mean different things when we say "good".
On a different machine I moved from fedora to gentoo. Fedora at least is not compiled specifically for my architecture. I was using the 3D desktop and it was very sluggish on that hardware with fedora. With gentoo it was smooth as silk. It being easier and more geard towards customisation also make it easier to avoid things that slow down the system, but at least in my experience compiling for your architecture is noticable. I do like the customisation, but my main benfit of gentoo is speed. Another thing I like is the lack of conventional releases. You use USE flags and other settings to decide what you want and how up to date you want your system. So when a new release comes around for a component, e.g. Gnome 2.26, you can update to it early if you like, and risk a bit of unstability or wait longer. Its up to you and much easier than upgrading to a new release of the distro itself as with most distros (at least I always had trouble with upgrading on other distros I have tried). So SBN, what sort of hardware do you have? I also hope you don't mind the command line (the terminal)... Mons |
Hey thanks for the replies guys.
Im just curious about Gentoo because my co-worker said that its customizable, which is what i want in a box. Now i just want to get some inputs regarding the benefits of Gentoo its good side and bad side and how does it stand over the other popular distros. Also can Gentoo be used in servers. For my box its an old 1.2gz AMD Athlon. |
Gentoo can be used in servers : select correct USE flags, install packages, configure security (SELinux...) and off you go...
As for your box, I run Gentoo on an old box like this, and my first mistake was to not select USE flags aggresively enough and not selecting lightweight packages, and had to wait for two days to at least get a basic system running/perform a monthly upgrade for a box that was a bit overwhelmed by what I wanted from it. After selecting correct USE flags and changing some packages, the entire system recompiles under two days and the box is very usable. |
Quote:
For me the good is customizability, the bad is compiling times, but that is to be expected and is not a big problem for me. Quote:
Quote:
Of course this all comes to a cost, a system is only as secure as knowledgeable is its administrator. |
I don't know your background, but a lot of peoples compare Gentoo as the FreeBSD Linux version.
There a lot of things that you can compare between FreeBSD and Gentoo. Look at the portage tree, it's almost the same as the ports on FreeBSD, I mean the category inside /usr/ports vs /usr/portage. For the rest, Gentoo is a rolling release, so you don't need to reinstall your box every 6 months :P |
Hello.
Is being similar to FreeBSD a good thing? |
No. It's only a fact. :p
Seriously, that entirely depends on who do you ask to. Is a hammer any good? The answer is that hammers have no morality, they aren't good or bad. It depends on the task that you have between hands. It certainly is not the best to cut wires, but it's the absolute number 1 when all you want is to smash something into a wall, even if that "something" is your own finger sometimes hehe. Gentoo is customizable. Is customizability a good thing? Well, if you want to tailor every single piece of the system -starting from the very core- with your own hands then it's the best OS around the world. If you want a click'n'run system then Gentoo is very bad. |
If that ["The answer is that hammers have no morality, they aren't good or bad."] is the answer then it was either a ridiculous question or the person responding misunderstood. I would've figured "Is a hammer any good?" actually means: "Does a hammer have any use?" [I believe dictionary.reference.com supports me in this]. The answer: "yes".
I suppose you were trying to make an analogy between the hammer and "gentoo is similar to freebsd" [a poor analogy indeed, in my opinion]. It is difficult to find a proper response to your last paragraph [I will not enumerate the reasons]. Gentoo is customizable, but so are many others. I don't see anything 'bad' about that particular aspect. I can't agree to Gentoo being "the best <anything>" - this is obviously your opinion. These are the Gentoo subforums, so I will not say things such as: what about Linux From Scratch, Lunar Linux, SourceMage GNU/Linux, etc. In any case, I asked "Is being similar to FreeBSD a good thing?" because d2_racing had made the comparison between Gentoo and FreeBSD - I was trying to find out his opinion. |
Quote:
Quote:
I know that there are lots of ways to achieve the same things that Gentoo does. I just find it the most convenient one (you are right that's just a personal opinion), but I wouldn't even dare to imply that it's the best for everyone in the planet. Quote:
Maybe you were expecting to know about the similarities between both of them. In my opinion, there's the fact that ebuilds are similar to ports (which again is not good or bad, it's simply a fact). For me, the similarities between Gentoo and FreeBSD almost end there, except for a few other details. The OS is different, and the whole concept of BSD systems is completely different when compared to a linux system, starting from the kernel and the toolchain and how these two core components interrelate. For me, portage being based in ports is a good thing, for others it's horrid. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:20 PM. |